Cold-Call Conversation Rates by Seniority (From 598K+ Real Dials)
- Cormac Repman
- Aug 24
- 2 min read
We analysed 598,134 real cold calls to answer a question every SDR leader argues about: does seniority change your odds of an actual conversation?
For this analysis, a conversation means a live human talking for 60 seconds or more. Voicemails, hang-ups, and gatekeeper bounces don't count. Here is how the numbers break down by title tier:
Individual / Other: 3.2% conversation rate across 316,512 dials
Manager: 2.9% conversation rate across 11,244 dials
VP / Director: 2.5% conversation rate across 52,909 dials
C-suite / Founder: 2.3% conversation rate across 188,616 dials
What the data actually shows
The pattern is clean and monotonic. As seniority rises, conversation rate falls. Individual contributors and other non-management titles pick up and talk 3.2% of the time. C-suite and founders sit at the bottom at 2.3%. That is a gap of 0.9 points, and it is not a small-sample artefact: the two ends of the spectrum account for 316,512 and 188,616 dials respectively, more than half a million calls between them.
Put another way, for every 1,000 dials you make into C-suite and founder titles, you should expect roughly 23 real conversations. The same 1,000 dials into individual contributors returns roughly 32. That is about 40% more conversations from the same calling effort.
Why this matters for fintech and insurtech teams
The obvious reading is "call lower in the org chart." That is the wrong takeaway, and it is worth being precise about why.
This data measures who *talks*, not who is worth talking to. A conversation with a VP or C-suite buyer at an insurtech carrier, a payments platform, or a lending business can be worth several conversations with someone who cannot sign, cannot budget, and cannot champion internally. The harder-to-reach tier is often the right target precisely because the deal size and authority justify the lower hit rate.
So the question is not "which tier answers most?" It is "what does each conversation need to be worth to justify the dial cost at that tier?" With the rates above, a C-suite conversation only needs to be about 40% more valuable than an IC conversation to break even on calling effort. In most fintech and insurtech sales motions, where the C-suite conversation controls the budget, that bar is cleared easily.
The practical takeaway
Stop debating seniority as a volume question and treat it as a targeting decision.
1. Segment your dial list by title tier and set separate conversation-rate benchmarks for each. Do not judge a rep calling founders against a rep calling ICs.
2. Model expected conversations per 1,000 dials using the rates above, then attach your own pipeline value per tier. Whichever tier produces the most pipeline per dial, not the most conversations per dial, is where your calling hours belong.
3. If you need C-suite conversations, budget for more dials per meeting up front rather than discovering the gap mid-quarter.
Deliberate targeting beats raw volume every time. Seniority costs you conversations, but the right conversations are usually worth the cost.
Comments